top 10 current NFL qb's?

I find it ironic how the best rushing teams all have losing records.

yeah that is wild, its usually the exact opposite.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by starbuck

what is your list for the top 10 current active NFL QB's?

1. T Brady
2. P Manning
3. D Brees
4. B Roethlisberger
5. K Warner
6. D McNabb
7. P Rivers
8. A. Rodgers
9. Matt Ryan (don't like to pick after one year in the league though)
10. C Palmer (iffy on this too because of injury but if healthy...)

Cutler and Romo don't make my list because both have to prove they can win late in the season and Eli Manning ....without Plax seems a little lost but he seems to have improved since the SB win in certain areas. I do think this will be McNabbs last great chance for a SB ring as a starter. I'd almost rank Brees as the best QB if he had just one ring. The man is maybe the best pure passing QB we have seen since Marino. If N.O. could just give him a good "D" it would be scary. Big Ben is kind of Favre like. Will take chances, some big chances. maybe not the best TD to INT ratio but the man can win a game when it is all on the line.

---

after a great season my rankings get shaken up just a little.

1. P. Manning
2. Brees
3. Brady he wasn't right this season. still put up great numbers
4. Roethlisberger
5. Warner (without him AZ is not a playoff team)
6. Rivers
7. Rodgers
8. Favre
9. Romo
10. E. Manning

I had McNabb at #10 and in a lot of ways I think I should have kept him there but little Manning impressed me. The Giants may have flopped but Manning had a really god year. You can't judge McNabb on the last 2 games either because he played really good this year too. At #6 Rivers feels a little underrated but I'm not taking him above Warner or Ben. Warner retires and Rivers in solid in the top 10. Palmer and Ryan both drop out of my top 10 along with McNabb, replaced by E Manning, Favre and Romo. I think just like with Eli when Shocky was let go, Romo was allowed to grow into a team leader without TO around, plus I think his off field distractions were limited this year.


so, after a season of watching and shuffling, what is your new top 10??

top 3 still the same, and prolly will be for still a long time

manning
brady
brees

then its guys like warner, romo, rodgers, rivers, palmer *who really let me down this year,i expected big things* mcnabb, big ben

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by starbuck

after a great season my rankings get shaken up just a little.

1. P. Manning
2. Brees
3. Brady he wasn't right this season. still put up great numbers
4. Roethlisberger
5. Warner (with him AZ is not a playoff team)
6. Rivers
7. Rodgers
8. Favre
9. Romo
10. E. Manning

I had McNabb at #10 and in a lot of ways I think I should have kept him there but little Manning impressed me. The Giants may have flopped but Manning had a really god year. You can't judge McNabb on the last 2 games either because he played really good this year too. At #6 Rivers feels a little underrated but I'm not taking him above Warner or Ben. Warner retires and Rivers in solid in the top 10. Palmer and Ryan both drop out of my top 10 along with McNabb, replaced by E Manning, Favre and Romo. I think just like with Eli when Shocky was let go, Romo was allowed to grow into a team leader without TO around, plus I think his off field distractions were limited this year.


so, after a season of watching and shuffling, what is your new top 10??

---

how the heck can you say that with warner ARI is not a playoff team? i hope that is a typo. besides that i agree with every bit of your list except for Eli even being ranked.

The top 4 has not changed this season other than 1 moving up and down in that top 4

1. P. Manning
2. Brees
3. Brady
4. Roethlisberger

After the top 4 which there is a clear separation...

5. Warner
6. Rivers
7. Rodgers
8. Favre

After 6-8 it is a jumble between the next couple of...

Romo, Ryan, Eli Manning, Palmer (which he would be no better than 9 if not lower with his regression and what he showed the late part of the year) and McNabb

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rocky

how the heck can you say that with warner ARI is not a playoff team? i hope that is a typo. besides that i agree with every bit of your list except for Eli even being ranked.

---

typo. without Warner the Cards don't sniff the playoffs

you worried me there for a second i thought i was going to have to lock ya up : D

Manning
Brady
Warner

Yes, I put Warner in that group. Go ahead and give him his HOF jacket for his next press conference. Turned TWO terrible franchises into winners (STL, ARI) and where is STL without him? The cellar. Against "number one" defense in the NFC he had more touchdown passes than incompletions in the playoffs. He belongs here.

Next:
Brees
Rivers
Big Ben ( Missed the playoffs this year. Looks awful at times, holds on the the ball too long. Benefits from a GREAT d in his two SB years. He is lights out in clutch time though)

Favre
Romo
Rodgers
Palmer

And hopefully, Romo moves up this list very quickly....

yall are WAY higher on Ben than i am. he may be the most overrated player in the NFL IMO. He has a great set of WR's, a great TE, a very good rushing game and a nasty D.

OK, here are three guys, rank these three guys 1-3.
(Passer rating, Completion %, Yards, Yards Per Game, Touchdown, Interceptions)

#1: 98.6, 67.9%, 4770, 298.1, 29 TD, 15 INT

#2: 100.5, 66.6%, 4328, 288.5, 26 TD, 12 INT

#3: 97.6, 63.1%, 4483, 280.2, 26 TD, 9 INT